Should we celebrate the fact that the Web has allowed numerous obscure social movements -- especially those that would otherwise be forgotten by history -- to flourish and gain new global following? 

In most cases, the answer is an unqualified "yes" since the effect on international affairs is generally benign. For example, the world's knitting community must be delighted to have sites like Knit Together, which provide a shared cultural reference point for knitting enthusiasts around the world (and almost certainly resulting in new horizontal connections - and, of course, better knitting). Sites like MeetUp sprang up precisely because it became possible to form new alliances and movements in very cheap and effective ways on any subject.

This mostly positive side of the story -- "the power of organizing without organizations" -- has been fairly well-covered by thinkers like Clay Shirky (the above quote also happens to be the title of Shirky's book). But what's happening on the other darker side could potentially be much more interesting. Why not study how technology helps various nutcases to join forces as well? Wouldn't this help us draw more insights into technology's "net effect" (excuse the pun)?

Take the world of conspiracy theorists. Arguably, it has flourished on the Web. Actually, there has never been a better time to be a conspiracy theorist than in the age of Google, when every single dubious resource is digitized and available for quoting. It doesn't matter if there are many more authoritative sources that disprove the theory; usually, this only strengthens theorists' distrust of the mainstream media.

Often, there is also a weird variation of the Streisand Effect at play here: the more authorities or the media try to reign in or engage with the conspiracy theorists, the more popular they tend to get. In this case, the best scenario is to really leave them alone for any additional publicity is only going to help them recruit new members. This is why I think the cyber-attack campaigns launched by Project Chanology against the Church of Scientology are likely to backfire; they're unlikely to silence that church forever, but it's now quite possible that more people will learn about Scientology by reading the story about cyber-attacks online.

Some cases are, however, unique in their weirdness. I doubt that the story below would even be possible in the pre-Internet age; that four people who live in different countries but are united by some weird belief would be able to meet, plan and executive a sabotage act is possible largely only thanks to email, Facebook, and instant messaging.

But even without the Internet angle, the story below - pasted almost in its entirety - is so rich in its eeriness that it could easily put any of Roberto Bolaño's novels to shame.

The four people accused by the Mozambican police of using a supposedly "highly corrosive substance" in an attempt to sabotage the Cahora Bassa dam are in fact members of a lunatic fringe group called "Orgonise Africa".

The four have now been named as Georg Ritschi (a German architect), Carlos Silva (a Portuguese hotelier), Tino Phutheso (a Botsanan aircraft pilot), and Joseph Ngusato (a South African self-styled "prophet").

There was nothing clandestine about this group's visit to the Cahora Bassa lake. They advertised it on their Internet websites, where they called the journey "Operation Paradise".

"Want to come on our next Zambezi expedition, April 2009?", asked Georg Ritschi on an "Orgonise Africa" blog. "Our next big expedition will be the continuation of our last great water gifting effort on the lower Zambezi", said Ritschi.

What can they possibly be talking about? Orgonise? Gifting?

It turns out that Orgonise Africa is a band of dedicated followers of the Austrian psychiatrist Wilhelm Reich, who died in an American jail in 1956. Reich did some valuable work on human sexuality in the early part of his career, but in his later years switched his political allegiance from left to right, and showed signs of mental illness and paranoia.

He claimed that he had discovered a universal form of energy which he called orgone. This energy - undetected by science both then and in the 52 years since Reich's death - was responsible for everything from the weather to gravity and the formation of galaxies. Reich built machines called orgone accumulators were supposed to concentrate orgone energy. This would be a good thing since, according to Reich, illness and diseases are caused by insufficient orgone.

The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) correctly described the orgone accumulators as fraudulent, banned their sale and outlawed all "orgone therapy". Which was why, after he defied the injunction obtained by the FDA, Reich ended up in jail.

........

The theory espoused by this group is that everything wrong with the planet is due to a lack of orgone. To set matters right, the dedicated followers of Wilhelm Reich, engage in "orgone gifting". This involves dumping "gifts" of a substance called orgonite into the place - in this case, Cahora Bassa lake - that is to be cured of its orgone deficiency.

So that is what the four arrested "saboteurs" were doing - heaving lumps of orgonite from a boat into the lake.

I find it quite amazing that such fringe groups can be extremely effective. Just look at the Web-site of Orgonise Africa -- it has a pretty map, a blog, an online shop, and even an affiliate program. Not only does it look legit to most people, its narrative is appealing enough to help recruit new supporters on a monthly (if not weekly) basis. Not surprisingly, the Web plays a significant role here too:

...Enthusiasts for orgonite tell us how to make the stuff on their Internet sites...A site called organite.info tells us "Quarter-inch-wide aluminum curls are very common and very effective for use in orgonite, but any kind of copper, iron, brass (including brassed aluminum), bronze, nickel or even steel shavings will work fine. Just bring a bucket and some work gloves to a local machine shop and ask them if you can fill your bucket with metal shavings".

Even more interesting is the ambivalence with which some of these groups treat technology. For them, it's not only a good weapon, it's also a weapon that is increasingly used against them -- or so they think: 

They don't like cell phones either, and claim that "the ubiquitous microwave transmitters, sold to the populace as necessary for cell phone communications play a major role in the undeclared war against humankind".

Orgonise Africa declares that its mission is "to reverse the negative effects of entropic technology and secret bio-chemical warfare" on Africa. Its strategy is to lay down organite and orgone devices so as to "neutralise at least most of the entropy transmitters in one country and other obvious sources of negative energy such as battle fields, ritual murder sites, prisons, police stations and Masonic lodges".

It's quite disturbing to watch how technology is amplifying the impact of groups like this one: they are really too weird and obscure to be on the radar of most people - and yet, recruiting even four people could be enough to dump quite a lot of useless junk into a lake. Perhaps, some of my recent fears about Twitter and misinformation were not so ungrounded; I can see how a group like the Orgonise Africa would be all over it, if only to recruit one extra member... 

 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

LILLY VON MARCAB

2:12 AM ET

May 9, 2009

It's a shame you didn't do any research at all about Chanology

You could be excused if you had written this article around mid-January 2008, if you think Project Chanology consists of cyber-attacks. Indeed, that's what it was for few days that month (mostly DDOS). Then they stopped this, in favor of a real-life approach. That was almost a year and a half ago. It very quickly changed to a worldwide movement of thousands of people, of all ages, from all walks of life, dedicated to exposing the Scientology criminal organization. We do this through frequent protests at their locations; just as importantly, there is now essentially an army of dedicated researchers digging up evidence, preparing materials for political leaders and law enforcement, writing articles for educating the general public, and much more.

Your point about more people learning about Scientology: That would be good! People SHOULD learn more about Scientology. It is definitely not just a "weird" UFO cult for celebrities. It is a vicious and dangerous criminal organization. Anyone doing 30 minutes of research about Scientology -- on sites NOT run by Scientology or its numerous front groups -- will find abundant documented evidence of this cult's criminality.

Top 10 Things Most People Don't Know About Scientology:
1. Has an internal carceral system for staff
2. Pregnant staff face strong coercion to abort
3. Widespread visa fraud and human trafficking ("religious worker" visas)
4. Scientology and IRS made a secret deal to let Scientology be a religion. Full details of how this came about are still "secret" and not subject to FOIA.
5. Because of this deal, Scientologists receive special tax benefits not granted to any other religion, group, or person in the USA. Tuition for their kids to go to private school is tax-deductible. Do you have that?
6. Scientology owns a 440-foot ocean liner cruise ship, the Freewinds, based in the Caribbean. Scientologists can go on tax-deductible Caribbean cruises. Do you have that?
7. The cult's #1 goal in the world is the "global obliteration of Psychiatry." They are prepared to use all measures, including violence, to accomplish this.
8. Scientologists passionately believe that Psychiatrists are to blame for the African slave trade, the Spanish Inquisition, the Holocaust, 9/11, and every other bad thing you can think of. Why? Because psychiatrists did some mean stuff to them in outer space, 75 million years ago.
9. Scientology's core policy of "Fair Game," in which all critics of Scientology should be "tricked, sued, lied to and destroyed," has ruined the lives of many innocent people, with false accusations, smear campaigns, stalking, cat-killing, and many other dirty tricks. Not to mention the many members whom they have bankrupted with the hard sell of expensive products, many of which they already own.
10. Scientology does not have the millions of members it claims. In reality, it has about 55,000 worldwide, and declining. Nor are any of its front groups benevolent, humane members of civil society. EVERYTHING in Scientology works toward "the global obliteration of psychiatry."

So yes, please learn more about Scientology. Here's a few places to start:

http://www.xenu-directory.net
http://www.xenu.net
http://www.scientology-exposed.org
http://www.scientology-kills.org
http://www.whyweprotest.net

 

MAJA007

9:21 PM ET

May 12, 2009

How is it different from

How is it different from Christianity (Catholicism in particular)

1. Has an internal carceral system for staff

VATICAN

2. Pregnant staff face strong coercion to abort

Catholic staff are not even allowed to marry.

3. Widespread visa fraud and human trafficking ("religious worker" visas)

So does many churches.

4. Scientology and IRS made a secret deal to let Scientology be a religion. Full details of how this came about are still "secret" and not subject to FOIA.

Why should religions get special treatment anyways.

5. Because of this deal, Scientologists receive special tax benefits not granted to any other religion, group, or person in the USA. Tuition for their kids to go to private school is tax-deductible. Do you have that?

Same with christian schools.

6. Scientology owns a 440-foot ocean liner cruise ship, the Freewinds, based in the Caribbean. Scientologists can go on tax-deductible Caribbean cruises. Do you have that?

Have you seen pope's house? Its a whole country!

7. The cult's #1 goal in the world is the "global obliteration of Psychiatry." They are prepared to use all measures, including violence, to accomplish this.

Church has used violence 1000s of time.

8. Scientologists passionately believe that Psychiatrists are to blame for the African slave trade, the Spanish Inquisition, the Holocaust, 9/11, and every other bad thing you can think of. Why? Because psychiatrists did some mean stuff to them in outer space, 75 million years ago.

Spanish inquisition. Hmmmm. Wondering who is responsible for that!

9. Scientology's core policy of "Fair Game," in which all critics of Scientology should be "tricked, sued, lied to and destroyed," has ruined the lives of many innocent people, with false accusations, smear campaigns, stalking, cat-killing, and many other dirty tricks. Not to mention the many members whom they have bankrupted with the hard sell of expensive products, many of which they already own.

One name: Galileo

10. Scientology does not have the millions of members it claims. In reality, it has about 55,000 worldwide, and declining. Nor are any of its front groups benevolent, humane members of civil society. EVERYTHING in Scientology works toward "the global obliteration of psychiatry."

Yes. They are fooling only half a million people. Unlike somebody who is fooling 2 billion.

Scientology is a weird religion. But it is not even close to being the most evil religion.

 

XN8D

5:26 PM ET

May 15, 2009

Don't fall into religion comparison trap

This line of defense are due to (Tom) Newton's laws, and only works for Scientologists and those who didn't think twice about it.

If someone try to change the current law and constitutional of the land without going through the democratic process, it is anti-society and had to be stopped, be it Scn law or Muslim law or Christian law.

This guy compare celibacy and coercion abortion, like S&M and rape are similar. Don't waste your time on his other arguments.

Other religions don't setup front groups, sneak into schools to preach their version of anti-drug and human rights, which promote their founder, their detox money making scheme, and how bad psychiatry is. Other front groups like APS, Criminon are getting govt money, which is your money.

Other religions don't setup front groups to influence politicians, while keeping their religion tax exempt status. The whole of NFWL kept pushing pro-scientology legislation so Scn can grasp more power and money.

 

LILLY VON MARCAB

4:18 AM ET

May 25, 2009

You yourself don't believe your retorts

You're grasping at straw arguments, just so you can say you won. The Catholic Church has had an enormous amount of violence and abuse and excess over the years, but we're talking about a criminal organization that used "religious cloaking" as a money-making strategy. And yes, we have documentation of this.

With regard to your retorts:

1. No, the Vatican is not a carceral system. Do you know what "carceral" means?
2. Coerced ABORTION is the same as voluntary celibacy, something known to future priests and nuns before they even join? No.
3. Oh really? Give some examples.
4. You seem to be agreeing with me. However, Scientology got special treatment that real religions DON'T get.
5. You are incorrect. Members of no other religious group can deduct private school expenses.
6. Apples and oranges again.
7. So, it's really OK for Scientology to use violence, right?
8. We're talking about NOW, not 500 years ago.
9. It's quite a different situation. Also, we're talking about NOW, not 500 years ago.
10. No-one said it was "the most evil religion." It is, however, a bad and abusive criminal organization that we can actually do something about, if enough people like you would pull their heads out of their asses. ;^)

 

GHH

7:08 PM ET

May 9, 2009

Orgonite's effect on plants

Orgonite has a positive effect on the growth of plants, and it can be independently tested as shown in this article:

http://img520.imageshack.us/img520/1742/ftorgonite.jpg

 

XN8D

6:20 PM ET

May 10, 2009

Project Chanology is to expose Scientology, not silence

Who in their right mind would think the purpose of cyber-attack is to silence their opponents forever? For the rich and powerful cult of Scientology, anybody knows the disruption would only be temporary. It's like civil disobedience and climbing the Golden Gate Bridge to protest. So "backfire" is irrelevant, and the purpose of attracting the public's attention is achieved. May is the 16th month of non-stop worldwide protests.

I don't endorse illegal activities and the DDOS against the cult of Scientology were started by some group of people and since stopped and denounced within chanology. However, in my opinion, using other people's computer illegally as an army of zombies to disrupt some websites, which costs lost of revenue, is illegal. But using one's own computer, joining forces with thousands of people worldwide, using scripts to speed up browsing and searching of some websites, is comparable to picketing in the real world, and should be legal.

 

XN8D

6:39 PM ET

May 10, 2009

What conspiracy theorists can recruit

Take the Zeigeist Movie. It's very powerful if everything were true. What happened when you watched the movie and went to their website? Nothing to sustain the claims. If they list their research somewhere, it's too difficult to find for me. So those without critical thinking, and lazy to check facts, will fall for it. At worst, we will be back to the bad old days, when superstition is rampant. But then, how many believe in horoscope?

Incidentally, I encountered some ordinary Scientologists who fall in love with that Movie, which looks very similar to what they have seen brainwashed - psychiatrist are responsible for the Holocaust, 911, school shootings and many other things. Seeing that the cult of Scientologist suffers from the Internet, I claim that the Internet is actually bad for conspiracy theorists. Everybody may know your theory, but empty theory will be obvious. Most people will scrutinize your theory like buying from eBay, which is hard for the sellers.

 

Evgeny Morozov, originally from Belarus, is a visiting scholar at Stanford and a Schwartz Fellow at the New America Foundation.

Read More