Friday, June 5, 2009 - 1:28 PM
Apparently, Facebook is not ready to defend all political speech. It's okay to deny the Holocaust on Facebook, but it is not okay to comment on the political situation in Kenya. Could Facebook be a bit, umm, more coherent in what type of political speech it is going to protect?
The first Kenyan photojournalist to win the CNN Multichoice Journalist Award has been banned by social networking site Facebook. Boniface Mwangi who won the CNN Africa Photojournalist of the Year 2008 is starting up a new Facebook profile after his was deleted last week due to his radical status updates.
Commenting on the issue he said, “I was removed from Facebook due to controversial updates calling for political change and the youth to stop hero worshiping tribal leaders who have messed up our country.” One of his last comments before his profile was deleted was “Kenyans elect criminals to parliament all you need is money to get elected.” He had over 1,500 friends.
I am just curious: do cases like this lead to more self-censorship among Facebook users? I mean, if you see one of your Facebook friends deleted for saying what's on his mind with regards to local politics, would you also be more prone to shut up? Of course, you could always set up a new account but it's always a bit of a hassle, plus you lose all the "social" capital you've acquired on your old one: the wall, the applications, etc.
Maybe I'm giving Facebook a more western centric attitude than they deserve, but why would they care/are pressured by Kenyan politics? Is there an intermediary here I'm missing?
That was my first thought, I wonder if they let comments about "less violent" or more democratic governments slide by. Just think of all the swipes that Bush, Blair and others probably have taken over the years. And Kenya?!?! huh..really weird.
Evgeny Morozov, originally from Belarus, is a visiting scholar at Stanford and a Schwartz Fellow at the New America Foundation.
Read More
(3)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE