Posted By Evgeny Morozov Share

My Newsweek op-ed of a few weeks ago urged Amazon to share their best product with the rest of the world and make Kindles available elsewhere, if only to help advance American interests abroad (free and unencumbered access to information is definitely one of them).

Today Amazon unveiled an international version of their basic Kindle model, which would be able to wirelessly download books in more than 100 countries. There will also be an international model of Kindle DX arriving sometime next year.

What does it mean for the future of knowledge, especially in the developing world? The ability to download books wirelessly is definitely a much-needed feature that would grow Amazon's customer base worldwide. However, this feature is useless unless it's matched by the ability to buy book titles and/or subscribe to newspapers and magazines at prices far below those in North America and Western Europe. So far, there has been no indication that Amazon's Kindle Store would rely on a differianted pricing strategy, whereby users in poorer countries would be able to buy Amazon e-titles at reduced prices.

If Amazon expects that Kindle users in the developing would would buy ebooks at the same prices as their richer peers, its strategy is doomed. Instead it should be prepared that Kindle would become the number one gadget for swaping pirated books: it's hard to expect that Kindle users in Africa or Central Asia would fork out 10 bucks for an ebook that they can download online for free. From this perspective, the ability to download books via a wireless connection doesn't really add much value: the pirated books would still be predominantly loaded to Kindle via cables rather than wireless. The only real change is that now these gadgets can ship internationally - not exactly a sea change.

Another shortcoming of the current expansion strategy is that the Kindle store currently offers a very limited selection of newspapers and magazines from abroad. For example, one can't still subscribe to any publications from Brazil, Russia or India (China is only represented by the English-language Shanghai Daily). Of course, if Amazon succeeds in negotating with top media titles in these 100 countries, this would be a major coup for Kindle's fans abroad. Somehow, however, I don't think that this is going to happen anytime soon. Thus, there is a very good chance that Kindle users abroad would get stuck with having to read with American and a handful of English newspapers - I doubt this will fundamentally reshape the marketplace of global ideas.

In other words, while this is a good first global step on Amazon's behalf, this is hardly enough. So far it looks more like a strategy to tap into the lucrative market of American expats (and, perhaps, frequently travelling Kindle-obsessed business executives) than the beginning of a genuine engagement with foreign readers. You can do better, Amazon!
 

GRANT

12:13 AM ET

October 8, 2009

Given the fate of a certain

Given the fate of a certain 1984 on Kindle not too long ago I'm not sure how many people want to risk Kindle. To paraphrase a comment on downloaded music 'you can buy it and break the law when you want to keep it on something more permanent and less likely to be taken away than your machine or you can break the law when you download it and don't pay for it, either way you're still guilty'.

 

FASHION

1:08 AM ET

October 10, 2009

nice post really , and also

nice post really , and also wanna share some nice ugg boots ,especially ugg classic tall boots.

 

STAVROS

3:10 AM ET

October 16, 2009

"domestic" driving "foreign" market

You hit the nail on the head about price. Books in countries like Russia are far cheaper than in North America full stop, so paying even $15 for a title would be outrages in the Ukraine yet perceived as a deal in France.

I suspect that Amazon has not given the real foreign market, ie beyond ex-pats, that much thought. Yet I would not underrate the value of the English speaking market and ex-pats. In the end the type of people who learn English and ex-pats abroad read at a higher percentage, have a disproportionate influence and establish trends.

I agree that you are unfortunately correct that titles beyond English appear to be of little interest. Yet I believe this will change in a counterintuitive way. The diaspora population will drive new tiles (newspapers, magazines...) to be consumed in western countries, which will in the end find a larger market in the country/region of their origin.

About six months ago on a regional commuter train in the Toronto area I saw a woman reading a book in Russian on an e-book devise (the Kindle is not available in Canada and shockingly is not one of the next 100).

Anything electronic will be far cheaper that purchasing overseas material so I see a natural market as those who are unwilling to buy expensive imported books may become "new" customers in electronic form.

 

Evgeny Morozov, originally from Belarus, is a visiting scholar at Stanford and a Schwartz Fellow at the New America Foundation.

Read More